Motivated Reasoning

Motivated Reasoning is a Cognitive bias - we tend to accept/believe more easily and with less scrutiny things we think are correct. If we encounter an idea that we think is wrong, we subject it to more scrutiny - it has a higher bar to clear for us to accept it.

Eg. Say we are an Atheist. If we see a article that says Atheist are found to be more rational, we accept it easily. But when we see an article that says Religious people have less mental health issues, we require multiple studies before accepting it.

A sutler form of this is holding opposing views to a higher standard of proof(sample size of that study is too low, the author of that study is not qualified enough), while being lenient towards confirming viewpoints.

The reason for this is people tend to avoid unflattering/troubling information that contradicts their self image - this behavior helps in maintaining a positive self image. When encountering formation that goes against their currently held believes, they have a Cognitive Dissonance which is uncomfortable.

This is very close to Confirmation Bias.

The opposite is a scout mindset.

Counteract Motivated Reasoning

  • Save critical thinking for things that matter - prioritize the investment in time and effort for decisions with important consequences.
  • Take time to reflect on your knowledge and its limits.
  • Think of four compelling points for and against a given position.
  • Be attentive to situations in which you’re motivated to prove yourself right, which can render you vulnerable to reasoning errors.
  • Avoid jumping to conclusions based on what you think others know, because assumptions are often baseless.
Links to this note

Memory Filters

Before we store an event in our memory, it goes thru many filters. So the final memory is very different from the actual event. The filters are... Delete Distort Generalize Personalizations Before it reaches our memory storage.

Risk Schmisk - Annie Duke

Expected Value: Theoretical net positive or negative of a given event over time. Volatility > Luck: How much variation there is around the expected value Risk Management: How much should should be invested in an event proportional to the

Confirmation Bias

Confirmation bias is the tendency to... search for interpret favorably favor recall information ... data/evidence in a way that confirms or supports one's prior beliefs or values. This reinforces preexisting beliefs - once a b

Why saying I don't know is a key to success - Poker champion Annie Duke

We have to embrace uncertainty. We have been taught that "I don't know" as a bad state of mind. But in most case it is an accurate model of the world. The more accurate our maps are, the better our decision mak

Thinking in Bets

Beliefs are bets on the future. If we think of our belief/decision as bets, we would be more open to challenge/change it, rather than be tied to it. Good way to challenge a belief is to ask "How much will you bet on that?" If we have a

Motivated Belief

Motivated Belief is when a person believes something because they want it to be true, not necessarily because that belief is supported by facts or other evidence. Related - Motivated Reasoning

Exploratory vs Conformatary Thought

If people make judgments without needing to explain themselves to others at some point, they are more likely to use gut feelings and jump to conclusion. If people think they have to explain, they will use more reason in coming to their jud

Social Media Distorts Sense making

We are programmed to observe the world and generalize our experiences into mental modals that can be used to understand and predict the world. Social Media can distort this by showing very rare events fairly often - tricking us into think

Meta

Published on: Jul 21, 2020

Tagged With: